A phone round in a noisy carriage can still be useful if you change one variable.
A commute is one of the few reliable slots in a busy day, and it is also one of the worst listening environments. Train rumble, station announcements, a podcast two seats away. The instinct is to skip the round; the better move is to change what you are measuring.
On noisy days I do not try to identify the song. I try to identify one audio feature: is the vocal dry or processed, is the drum a kit or a loop, is the low end busy or simple. One feature, one line, done. The round may end in a guess, but the practice is the observation, and observations survive noise much better than titles do.
Headphones help, but they are not essential. What matters is that the same pair of ears hears the same thing twice, so consistency beats quality. The commuter who uses the same earbuds every day builds a stable reference; the player who switches devices every day resets the reference each time.
There is also a logistical trick: play the round before you arrive. Tapping out a guess while walking through a ticket barrier is how rounds turn into reflexes. A round at practice rounds on the platform is worth more than three hurried ones in the street.
The commute will never be the best listening room. It can still be the most consistent one, and consistency is what a daily habit is actually made of. The point of a commute round is not volume but continuity. Ten observations made on a train are worth more than one perfect round at a desk, because continuity is what carries a skill through a month. Protect the slot, lower the ambition on noisy days, and the habit keeps its shape. It is not the perfect room; it is the one you will actually use.